Unsafe yet no rush

Nearly 12 months after hurtful hefty metals like cadmium, chromium and lead were found in many pesticides, the public authority is yet to implement obligatory tests to forestall imports of the contaminated synthetic substances, generally utilized in the nation's huge horticulture area. 

Bangladesh Food Safety Authority (BFSA) ordered tests at two assigned government research facilities before the arrival of imported pesticides from ports since February 1 this year. Yet, this date was broadened a few times following solicitations from merchants. 

"They [importers] mentioned us to suspend the ban thinking about the unfavorable impact on farming creation," Md Abdul Quayium Sarkar, executive of the BFSA, revealed to The Daily Star as of late. 

He said the shippers likewise asked further examination to quantify the destructive impacts of substantial metals in pesticides, adding that the Department of Agricultural Extension (DAE) is the applicable expert in such manner. 

The BFSA, on December 8 a year ago, first mentioned DAE to guarantee each transfer of imported pesticides be delivered from the port traditions dependent on tests at either the Bangladesh Atomic Energy Center (BAEC) or the Bangladesh Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (BCSIR), beginning from February 1 this year. 

Additionally, the BFSA likewise mentioned the DAE to punish organizations which advertised debased pesticides. 

"In tests, there was an elevated level of hefty metals in these pesticides. Hefty metals are seriously contaminating the evolved way of life… Most of the pesticides utilized in the nation are imported. There is a commitment to import pesticides liberated from weighty metals under the Pesticides Act," peruses the BFSA letter to the DAE. 

Nonetheless, following concerns noted by the Bangladesh Crop Protection Association (BCPA) and shippers, the BFSA expanded the cutoff time for compulsory testing of imported pesticides to July 1 this year prior to a further augmentation of a year. 

M Sayeduzzaman, executive of BCPA, an assemblage of business endeavors engaged with import, detailing and promoting of plant assurance synthetic compounds, said while the affiliation concurs there should be a standard admissible constraint of pesticides, the condition of pesticides in the nation can't be resolved until there is one. 

"We have requested the service to permit proceeding with imports until the selection from an allowable cutoff for substantial metals in pesticides," he added. 

Guaranteeing the degree of hefty metals discovered in pesticides to be "unimportant", he stated, "We primarily import pesticides from different nations. Future arrangement should be versatile to the global guidelines. Else, we won't have the option to import pesticides and this, over the long haul, will influence our food creation." 

BFSA Chairman Quaiyum stated, "We don't need something entering the nation hurting the climate – the farming division doesn't need that as well. Yet, we likewise don't need farming creation to be hampered. There should be a harmony between both. 

"We are yet to get any update from them [the DAE]," he added. 


The DAE – the summit pesticide administrative body – held its keep going gathering on the issue in February and shaped a warning panel to set up a rule on the admissible furthest reaches of hefty metals in pesticides. 

Be that as it may, the board of trustees is yet to present its report, as indicated by DAE authorities, and from that point forward, there has been no advancement till date. 

Reacting to a question on whether the nine months were adequately not to set up the rule, the BFSA director stated, "This is an issue identified with them, you better ask the horticultural service or the division [DAE]." 

The greatest permissible cutoff for substantial metals in manures utilized in the nation is characterized by the Fertilizer (Management) Regulation, 2007. 

For substantial metals in pesticides, there is no greatest admissible breaking point – either broadly or around the world. 

Notwithstanding, as indicated by condition 15.2 of the Bangladesh Pesticides Act, 2018, if any pesticide is discovered to be defiled or erroneously or misleadingly labeled, the public authority may control and boycott further import of that pesticide into the district. 

Yet, the import of pesticides presently happens without going through testing anyplace as long as the shippers are enrolled with the DAE. 

The nation's yearly use of pesticides is almost 38,000 tons – most of which, around 90%, is imported from China – as indicated by the DAE. There are 5,500 enlisted pesticide items in the nation. 

More than 300 organizations enrolled with the DAE for the most part import crop insurance synthetic compounds from China, the USA, Germany, Australia, India, Indonesia, and Singapore in mass; they then repackage them in more modest units in their offices prior to showcasing them at the ranchers' level. 

The organizations, in any case, need to have their definitions endorsed by the DAE prior to advertising the pesticides. 

The DAE just leads insignificant testing, for example, the effectiveness of the pesticide in executing nuisances and weeds and looking at its poisonousness on fish. 

Inquired as to whether the presence of weighty metals in pesticides is debasement, Dr Md Joynul Abedin, part secretary of the DAE warning advisory group, stated, "If there was any set breaking point, we could state it is defilement." 

Aminur Islam, extra delegate overseer of pesticide quality at the DAE, in any case, contested this. 

"The substance organization of pesticides is submitted at the hour of use for enrollment. There is no possibility of containing any poison past that. They [applicants] notice a hundred percent arrangement." 

To arrive at a decision about the breaking point, he stated, will require a controlled condition study. 

Approached about the course of events for setting up a rule on the allowable furthest reaches of substantial metals in pesticides, Joynul Abedin on Wednesday stated, "The warning board of trustees is yet to hold a gathering. They will sit in January-February to talk about the rule." 


The presence of hefty metals in the evolved way of life has raised concern countrywide in the course of the most recent couple of years. 

In that unique situation, the BFSA tried examples of 63 pesticides and 4 composts accessible in the market at the BAEC lab between November 2019 and January this year. BAEC has been a globally licensed lab since 2015. 

In any event 55 of these were likewise tried at a private lab. The two labs kept the standard F-AAS (Flame Atomic Absorption Spectrometry) testing technique. 

The test outcomes, a duplicate of which The Daily Star acquired, demonstrated 63 out of the 67 tried pesticides and composts contained critical degrees of cadmium, chromium or lead, or each of the three. 

The degree of substantial metals in some pesticide tests was disturbing. 

For example, BAEC's specialists found the most elevated level of lead, 12.70mg per kg, in an enemy of parasitic pesticide powder. 

Of the 47 examples in which lead was discovered, short of what 33% (14) contained lead beneath the identification furthest reaches of 0.02mg/kg while more than halfcontained lead going from 0.24-2mg/kg. Eight were found to contain more than 2mg lead per kg. 

Constant introduction to lead at generally low levels can bring about harm to the kidneys and liver, and to the regenerative, cardiovascular, invulnerable, hematopoietic, apprehensive, and gastrointestinal frameworks, as indicated by the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO). 

Moreover, transient presentation to high measures of lead can cause gastrointestinal pain, sickliness, encephalopathy, and demise. 

Decreased psychological and scholarly advancement in youngsters is the most basic impact of low-level lead introduction. 

FAO suggests ranchers try not to utilize aggravates that contain lead or might be tainted with lead in horticultural regions. 

BAEC's test likewise found that a normally utilized fluid pesticide contained 15.74mg chromium per kg. 

In another fluid pesticide, the BAEC test found around 7.19mg chromium, under 0.06mg cadmium, and around 6.49mg lead per kg. 

While the test results from the private lab shifted from BAEC's ones, the two labs recommended most of the pesticides contained these substantial metals. 

BAEC likewise independently tried four regularly utilized manures for just the degree of cadmium. 

Of these, a compost known as TSP was found to contain 13.96mg cadmium per kg – more than the greatest reasonable restriction of 10ppm (1ppm is identical to 1mg/kg) referenced in the Fertilizer (Management) Regulation, 2007. 


Specialists said no weighty metals should be available in pesticides, adding that its pollution of the natural way of life through pesticides is a genuine danger and long haul introduction may prompt general wellbeing chances. 

In spite of the fact that there is no greatest passable cutoff for hefty metals in pesticides, various specialists The Daily Star conversed with said the presence of substantial metals, even negligible sums, in pesticides is hurtful. 

"Weighty metals are not components of pesticides; consequently, these ought not be in pesticides. In the event that there is, the wellspring of pollution should be checked," Prof Dr Quazi Forhad Quadir of Bangladesh Agricultural University, disclosed to The Daily Star. 

"Pesticides themselves are destructive. Weighty metals – even in modest quantities – have a gathering impact," he added. 

Imrul Hasan, nation lead of USDA/USAID supported Food Safety Capacity Development for Bangladesh venture, revealed to The Daily Star, "If pesticides contain substantial metals, these will enter the evolved way of life – regardless of whether in little or enormous sums." 

Another master said a few organizations may be utilizing substantial metals as buildup in unacceptable and modest imported pesticides to acquire more benefits. 

Abdul Kaium, partner teacher of rural science at Sher-e-Bangla Agricultural University, stated, "The nature of pesticides relies upon the cost of its dynamic crude materials, or prepared items are imported. In our lab investigation, we discovered numerous pesticides have 50% less dynamic fixings than the depiction on the parcels. All things being equal, these contain more contaminations like substantial metals. 

"There are significant provisos in observation – from bringing in to stamp